Phyrexia: All Will Be One Prerelease

I was looking forward to the first prerelease of 2023, especially after previews suggested that Phyrexia: All Will be One would be a pretty powerful set. As usual, Christian and Noah were up for the prerelease. This time, we were joined by three of their friends.

After cracking my six packs and opening my promo, I looked over my pool. I had pulled an Atraxa, Grand Unifier, but I have a hard enough time building around three colours that I knew that building for four was a challenge for another time. My promo was a foil Tyvar, Jubilant Brawler. Definitely a better option to build around so I kept it handy. Another interesting pull was Jor Kadeen, First Goldwarden. Looking over the rest of my pool, I ruled out White and Red as neither offered sufficient depth. That left Jor Kadeen behind as well. Blue and Green stood out as the two strongest colours with Black as potential alternate to Blue or as a splashing colour.

I set out to build a BG deck focused around flyers, Oil counters, and Proliferate. It would have been nice to have more cards with Toxic to throw in to take more advantage of Proliferate. I looked to add a splash of Black but worried that a three-colour (Sultai) approach would prove as luckless as my previous attempts. In retrospect, it might have been the right strategy but I’m getting ahead of myself now.

First round and first hand, I immediately mulligan after pulling a one-land hand. I kept my second hand but stalled at two lands and watched my opponent grow out his board. While the third land finally did show, it was too late. The second hand went better and I started strongly before running into a few too many lands. And I learned that Toxic and Proliferate do indeed play well together.

With time in hand, we played a game for fun. And lo and behold, my deck suddenly came alive and worked as I had wanted it to. While it was too little too late, it did give me hope for the next rounds.

0-1.

In the second round, an explosive start in the first game by my opponent had me turning my creatures into blockers to simply stay alive when I could. One card that made a difference for him was Skrelv, Defector Mite. Making another card unblockable by creatures of a colour of his choice proved to be a real threat. And then he told me he had three! The second game was much closer but when he landed Atraxa, I knew the writing was on the wall. Kudos to him for playing that card!

0-2.

Round three and at the bottom of the rankings! Once again, I was quickly defeated, this time by none other than Morgan, one of Noah’s friends. While it looked for a time that I might finally at least win a game, it was not meant to be.

0-3.

Despite this less than stellar record, I had fun at the event. I love that the boys and I continue to be able to do this regularly. I think that we can count on the fingers of one hand the number of prereleases one of us has missed since we started going to them back when Oath of Gatewatch came out!

The boys also struggled with this prelease. Whereas at least one ends with a winning record, both of them ended with a 1-2 record. Sadly, even their friends ended with losing records. Just not our day!

As for this story, it does not end quite here. Every round at our LGS comes with two packs that players can either simply split or play to win for. I’ve always split them with whoever in the spirit of a prerelease. So despite my 0-3 record, I still walked away with three additional packs to crack open. Three card into the first of these, I found this:

Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines

Nothing quite as exciting in the rest of the packs but I did pull an alternate art Tyvar, Jubilant Brawler and a Red Sun’s Twilight.

The boys and I also still have our traditional box to open so there is still a lot of Magic to be played this weekend.

Cleric Tribal in Phyrexia: All Will Be One

The launch of Magic’s latest set, Phyrexia: All will be One, means that it’s once again time to take a look at what new Clerics have been added to the Standard pool. It’s also time to see if any of these will improve the Orzhov Cleric Tribal deck I like to play.

In case you’re just joining us on this journey, know that the last rotation was not kind to my deck with many crucial cards leaving the format and few good replacements have come to light since unfortunately.

To be honest, I haven’t played much with the deck since I made the last changes. The deck has a 73% winrate at the moment but with only 11 games in Standard B01 Play (not Ranked). I’ve won the last 5 games so maybe there is something still to the deck but I still doubt very much it would do as well in Ranked.

With Phyrexia: All Will Be One, there is a total of 10 new cleric cards to consider. Given that we’re playing Orzhov, three of them can be immediately ruled out. The seven that remain include a Legendary Cat Cleric and the following cards:

Given the type of deck I’m playing, cutting Kemba is an easy decision. This is not a Cat tribal deck; nor is it an equipment deck.

Annex Sentry is far more interesting. It is very reminiscent of Brutal Cathar which comes with the same exile ability. I like the fact that it has a toughness of 4. It will be harder to remove from the board than our friend the Cathar.

Cruel Grimnarch feels too expensive. By the time it can enter the battlefield, opponents may not have many cards left in hand.

Indoctrination Attendant also feels expensive but is more interesting. While Toxic 1 is not bad, the return creature to hand ability has limited synergy with the rest of my deck. It certainly has more potential in an Explorer or Pioneer deck where Cleric of Life’s Bond is still legal.

Mandible Justiciar just does not look like a card that I would pull something else out to use instead. Sure it has Lifelink but it is more suited for an artifact deck. Much the same argument can be made for Orthodoxy Enforcer.

Vivisection Evangelist is an expensive card. Without a focused approach using poison counters in the deck, its Corrupted ability will not consistently trigger, further reducing the appeal of this card. Pass.

My first instinct is to replace the recently added Yotian Medics with Annex Sentries. But that means losing some Lifelink depth, something that is needed to build up Voice of the Blessed into a potent threat. I could go deeper along this line and simply cut both Voices and replace them with other Clerics. Alternatively, I could cut the one March of Otherwordly Light and the two Liliana of the Veil, given Annex Sentry’s exile ability. Another option might be to cut the two Valorous Stances and the March, keeping Liliana.

A more drastic change to the deck could be to take on a third colour. Green does offer up a few more clerics with the arrival of the new set but at the cost of a wider mana base. There are no new Cleric cards in either Blue or Red so neither is an option. Back to Green, moving in that direction would likely mean a pivot to a deck more focused on the new Toxic ability. Maybe it’s worth building a separate deck to try this.

In the end, I think I will cut the March and one of the Yotian Medics in favour of 2 Annex Sentries. If the card performs well, I will look to replace more Medics or look at the Valorous Stances instead. More to come on this.

Here is the new deck that I will try once Phyrexia: All Will Be One launches on Arena.

Deck

  • 3 Infernal Grasp (MID) 107
  • 2 Anointed Peacekeeper (DMU) 2
  • 1 March of Otherworldly Light (NEO) 28
  • 2 Valorous Stance (VOW) 42
  • 3 Evolved Sleeper (DMU) 93
  • 9 Plains (THB) 250
  • 7 Swamp (THB) 252
  • 3 Shadow-Rite Priest (DMU) 106
  • 2 Voice of the Blessed (VOW) 44
  • 3 Shattered Sanctum (VOW) 264
  • 4 Lunarch Veteran (MID) 27
  • 2 Scoured Barrens (NEO) 274
  • 1 Takenuma, Abandoned Mire (NEO) 278
  • 2 Eiganjo, Seat of the Empire (NEO) 268
  • 2 Annex Sentry
  • 3 Yotian Medic (BRO)
  • 4 Markov Purifier (VOW) 241
  • 2 Loran’s escape (BRO)
  • 2 Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim (DMU) 198
  • 3 Phyrexian Missionary (DMU) 27
  • 2 Liliana of the Veil (DMU) 97

Sideboard (which I need to finish up!)

  • 2 Farewell (NEO) 13
  • 1 Cut Down (DMU) 89
  • 2 Chaplain of Alms (MID) 13
  • 1 Voice of the Blessed (VOW) 44
  • 1 Intercessor’s Arrest (NEO) 20

Feel free to drop a comment below with any suggestions for other changes.

A case of too much Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines?

Previews for Phyrexia: All Will Be One kicked off earlier this month. As the Phyrexian threat continues to grow and after seeing Praetors such as Gix, Jin-Jitaxias and Sheoldred, was it ever in question that Elesh Norn would make an appearance as well? She is after all the current leader of New Phyrexia.

Prior to the new card, Elesh Norn had only appeared on one card (Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite). Part of the New Phyrexia set, it has since been reprinted several times. So, Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines (or Mom as some have started calling this new one) is only the second appearance for the Praetor. Perhaps for this reason, WOTC decided to give us six versions of the same card.

As you can see above, we have the normal version as well as borderless, showcase, concept and oil slick versions. And one in Phyrexian.

It’s not the first time that Wizards of the Coast has cranked out multiple variants of the same card in a set. Two other recent examples are Teferi, Master of Time and Gala Greeters. The former featured mostly minor variants of the same art as well as a borderless version. The latter was the box topper for the set. Variants with unique art were offered for each language that the set came in.

My question is simple: Do we really need six versions of the same card in the set release? Different people will likely have different answers. Someone like Noah who does pay more attention to the art will be able to get the version he likes best. Someone like me will settle for the one I pull (hopefully) or the cheapest single version. And the completists will likely grumble at having to get multiple versions of the same card. In the end, some will not happy, some will scratch their heads and others will rejoice. Sounds like just another day in the world of Magic to me!

Lastly, if nothing else, it is six versions of a card that I expect will have an impact in at least some formats (like Commander). A five mana card is not always easy to play but you get a 4/7 with the ability to not only double our ETB (Enter the battlefield) triggers while suppressing those of our opponents. And in our house, that is a good thing!